While one of my favorite bands (and a cool poster idea), i believe the most essential part of the poster is the information. And when looking at the words, it’s very difficult to tell what is being said. So while the concept means well, it fails to deliver the message, which is the most important aspect of a poster.
I chose the Lost poster to represent what a good one should look like. It is visually stimulating, connects to the show and its audience who is viewing the poster, and it is easy to read. There are many little things, like the texture of the water, sky, shading of the land and trees. It also has buildings (skyscrapers) in the water, which play off of the palm trees, which is fun to look at as well.